When the premise moves, does the policy follow?
|
Mr. Cantrell owned a mobile home. At the time the mobile homeowners policy was issued, it was located in a mobile home park with clear access to a fire hydrant. However, during the policy term, Mr. Cantrell moved the home to a two-acre tract of land in another county. The setting may have been more picturesque but it was a mile away from the nearest fire hydrant.
Three months after the move, the mobile home and its contents were destroyed in a fire. Nationwide, his carrier, denied coverage because the mobile home wasn’t where the policy said it should be! Mr. Cantrell disagreed because there was no condition in the policy stating that he couldn’t move his home. He felt that the location information was for identification purposes only since the policy stated that the residence premises was located at the mailing address, unless otherwise shown. The defined term “residence premises” did not require that it be situated at any specific location.
The courts ruled that the wording was imprecise enough to rule that a reasonable man, such as Mr. Cantrell, could conclude that a mobile home could be moved without affecting coverage.
Click here for more detail on this court case. |