Volume 109

JANUARY 2016

Return to main screen

PF&M ANALYSIS:

WC 00 00 00 B–WORKERS COMPENSATION AND EMPLOYERS LIABILITY INSURANCE POLICY ANALYSIS

(December 2014)

INTRODUCTION

The National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc. (NCCI) developed WC 00 00 00 B–Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy. It covers the named insured's statutory liability under various state workers compensation laws or acts. It provides defined benefits to employees for injuries they sustain or diseases they contract that arise out of and in the course of their employment. All states have laws that require such protection for workers and those laws prescribe the amount and duration of the benefits provided. Employers Liability covers an employer's common law or tort liability for employee injuries that fall outside the scope of the state laws or acts. This liability is separate and distinct from the liability that workers compensation laws impose.

The policy provides the mandatory benefits that the various state laws prescribe and require for accidental work-related injuries that occur in the course of employment, subject to its terms and conditions. It must be emphasized that the injury must arise from and be related to the injured worker's job duties. Coverage also applies to the related costs for disease or death that occur as a result of the accident. There are times when the employed worker’s injury is not compensable under workers compensation or occupational disease laws. In those cases, Employers Liability coverage responds to the injured worker's allegations of negligence on the employer’s part, subject to its terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions. The coverage the basic policy provides may be broadened, restricted, clarified, or made to comply with specific state regulatory requirements by using a variety of available endorsements.

WC 00 00 00 B–WORKERS COMPENSATION AND EMPLOYERS LIABILITY INSURANCE POLICY ANALYSIS

Note: This analysis is of WC 00 00 00 B. This edition is effective 07/31/11. The one significant change from WC 00 00 00 A is in bold print.

The policy opens by explaining that the insurance company agrees to provide the coverages indicated in return for the named insured paying the premium. This is subject to all of the policy’s terms and conditions.

GENERAL SECTION

A. The Policy

The policy includes the Information Page and all endorsements and schedules listed on it as of its inception date. It is an insurance contract between the named insured employer and the insurance company identified on the Information Page. The only agreements that affect the insurance coverage provided are the ones stated in the policy. Policy terms and conditions cannot be changed or waived unless the insurance company does so by issuing written endorsements.

Note: Waiver means intentionally or voluntarily relinquishing a known right. As a result, this provision states that a written endorsement is needed to confirm that either party is surrendering a known right. The intent of this language is to prevent any oral agreements or unauthorized written agreements from being considered or treated as part of the insurance policy.

Example: Linda copies a brochure in the human resources office about Employers Liability coverage that describes the coverage the policy provides. She notices several statements to the effect that the brochure only describes the coverage. Linda wants to know exactly what coverage is provided and asks her human resources manager for a copy of the company’s actual policy to review.

B. Who Is Insured

The employer identified in Item 1. on the Information Page is the named insured. If the form of business is a partnership and the named insured is the partnership, an individual partner is considered an insured only to the extent of being the employer of the partnership's employees.

Note: Unlike many liability coverage forms and policies, the spouse of an individual, partner, member, or manager of a joint venture is not automatically included and covered as an insured. If the spouse is an employer, the spouse must be either named or have a separate policy that covers the operations for which the spouse is the employer.

Example: A partner in a law firm is an insured with respect to the employees of the law firm. However, he is not an insured for injuries to his household employees.

Note: WC 00 03 05–Joint Venture as Insured Endorsement makes each member of the joint venture an insured under a policy where the joint venture is a named insured. Similar to the partner as an insured, the member is an insured only with respect to the joint venture's employees.

Related Article: Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy Available Endorsements and Their Uses

C. Workers Compensation Law

The term "workers compensation law" means the workers compensation law(s) and the occupational disease law(s) of each state under Item 3. A. on the Information Page. It includes any changes in those laws enacted during the policy term. It does not include any federal workers compensation or occupational disease law(s) or any terms or provisions of any non-occupational disability benefits law(s). While it does not include federal laws, it does include territories if that territory is listed under Item 3. on the Information Page.

Note: It is important to note that U.S. territories can be listed and coverage provided but this requires additional work because the definition of state does not include territories. Before attempting to add a territory, it is very important to understand the insurance requirements and arrangements for the territories of Puerto Rico, the United States Virgin Islands, American Samoa, and Guam.

Note: Older versions of this policy included detailed citations of the various state laws. This is no longer necessary because workers compensation and occupational disease laws and statutes are readily available for review and are generally well known. This also means that changes in the law(s) that take place during the policy period are not endorsed to the policy as in the past. Because this paragraph specifically excludes federal workers compensation, occupational disease, or similar laws, special endorsements are available when such coverage is required.

Related Article: Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy Available Endorsements and Their Uses

D. State

When the term "state" is used anywhere in the policy, it means any state of the United States of America. It also includes the District of Columbia.

Note: Item C. above states that territories can be listed under Item 3 and be covered. However, this section does not broaden the definition of state to include territories.

E. Locations

Coverage applies to workplaces listed under Item 1 or Item 4 on the Information Page. It also covers all other workplaces in states listed under Item 3 unless other insurance or self-insurance covers them.

Notes:

This policy covers the named insured's total liability as any state workers compensation law establishes it. Some states have laws that require insuring this total liability under one policy. In states that do not have this requirement, it is possible to "carve out" certain workplaces and exclude them from coverage. An example of this is when a project uses a wrap-up program and all contractors that work within that wrap-up are covered under the wrap-up workers compensation program. WC 00 03 02–Designated Workplaces Exclusion Endorsement is used to carve out the coverage for the wrap-up project from the subcontractor’s policy.

Example: Big Boy Builders subcontracts with Joe’s Flooring Installations to install laminate floors in living/dining rooms in new homes it builds in an exclusive subdivision. All workers on this Big Boy construction project are covered under a wrap-up workers compensation program. Joe does not include any individual workers compensation premium in his costs because the wrap-up covers all workers compensation injuries. Joe can remove the project payroll from his policy by attaching WC 00 03 02–Designated Workplaces Exclusion Endorsement.

Multiple policies issued to insure various employers engaged in large construction projects can be combined for premium discount purposes where the law permits. The same insurance company or group must issue them and they must be limited to the applicable employer's work at the construction site. Similar coordinated policies are also permitted to address other related cases and circumstances.

Related Articles:

Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy Available Endorsements and Their Uses

Premium Discount Endorsement

Overview of Wrap-up Programs

PART ONE–WORKERS COMPENSATION INSURANCE

A. How This Insurance Applies

This insurance covers bodily injury by accident or bodily injury by disease, including death that results from either. This is subject to the following:

1. An Accident. Bodily injury due to an accident must occur during the policy period.

Example: Jordan Electrical’s policy period with Injury Prone Mutual is from 04/01/13 to 01/13/14 and with Better Care Mutual from 04/01/14 to 04/01/15. An employee, Kelly, is working on site and is shocked on 03/31/14 but continues to work. She suffers a heart attack 04/02/14 and is rushed to hospital. The attending doctors explained that the heart attack was a delayed reaction to the electrical shock she sustained two days earlier. Prone Mutual believes the bodily injury occurred on 04/02/14 with the heart attack but Better Care Mutual believes the bodily injury occurred at the time of the electrical shock.

2. Disease. When bodily injury is due to disease, the policy period that provides coverage is the one when the employee was last exposed to the conditions that either caused or aggravated the bodily injury by disease.

Related Court Cases:

Shipyard Carpenter’s Last Employer Liability for His Asbestos Exposure and Death Benefit

Workers Compensation Coverage Triggers on Date of Last Injurious Exposure

Example: Penelope worked as an administrative assistant for 15 years. She worked for five different employers. On 05/25/14, while employed by Major Insurance Agency, her doctor diagnosed the pain in her arms and shoulders as resulting from carpel tunnel syndrome. He explained that it was the result of her many years of typing. Only the Major Insurance Agency’s workers compensation policy in effect at the time of the diagnosis responds to the claim.

B. We Will Pay

The insurance company agrees to pay benefits promptly but only those benefits due from the named insured based on the workers compensation law that applies.

Notes: This is the basic insuring agreement and indemnity provision and is probably the most important section in the policy. It means the policy insures the employer's entire liability under the designated law or laws. Specific benefits are not listed because coverage depends on the state workers compensation law that applies, including any revisions or amendments that might affect a particular loss.

Coverage under this part is for unlimited dollar amounts for any specific accident as well as to any number of accidents that occur during the policy period. This is because of the way state workers compensation laws are structured and arranged. They provide for unlimited medical benefits to injured employees. Although disability benefits are limited to a given percentage of pre-accident wages, they are paid for the injured worker's lifetime or his or her surviving spouse’s lifetime.

By implication, this provision recognizes that the number of employees may vary and the employer may engage in new or different operations. In either case, the intent is to cover all operations and employees and respond to the full extent of every statutory liability the law imposes on the employer, except for payments it must make as outlined in section F. below.

C. We Will Defend

The insurance company has both the right and the duty to defend any claim, suit, or other legal action against the named insured with respect to benefits that this insurance coverage pays. . However, it is not obligated to defend any legal action that this insurance does not cover.

Note: The insurance company provides this defense provision at its own expense. It is similar to provisions in most other liability coverage forms and policies. The company retains and compensates legal counsel as necessary to properly represent the employer in lawsuits, administrative and judicial proceedings, and appeals. It can select legal counsel it deems appropriate as part of its right to defend, investigate, and settle claims. It also assumes defense costs without any monetary limitation. The company's duty to defend is broader than its duty to indemnify. Unless the claim's allegations clearly remove it from the scope of coverage, the company must defend until it is clearly established that the loss is not covered.

The insurance company also has the right to investigate and settle any claim or legal action.

Example: Jerad is a truck driver. He submits a claim for total disability because of an inoperable herniated disc that his doctor diagnosed. Jerad states that his pain is so bad he must stay in the house all the time. Just Checking Insurance Company hires an investigator to secretly follow Jerad for a week to verify his claims. The pictures of Jerad playing basketball and fixing his roof are used to justify Just Checking denying his claim.

D. We Will Also Pay

The insurance company also pays a number of costs and expenses as part of a claim, suit, or legal action it defends in addition to other amounts it pays. They include the following:

1. All reasonable expenses the named insured incurs at the company's request. However, this does not include loss of earnings.

2. Premiums for bonds to release attachments or for appeal bonds, up to amounts that this insurance pays

3. Costs of litigation assessed against the named insured

4. Interest on judgments as the law requires. However, this is only until the insurance company offers to pay the amount due.

5. Any and all expenses the insurance company incurs that relate to a claim, suit, or action

Example: This includes the costs that Just Checking Insurance Company incurred to investigate Jerad in the example above.

E. Other Insurance

More than one insurance company may be responsible for a particular loss. In that case, this insurance company does not pay more than its proportion or share of costs and benefits covered by all available sources. The other sources may be other insurance companies or self-insurance. All sources must contribute equally until the loss is paid. If the limits of any other insurance policy or self-insurance are used up, all remaining insurance pays in equal shares until the loss is completely paid.

Notes:

There may be cases where more than one workers compensation policy applies to a specific accident or occupational disease. In others, another arrangement, such as self-insurance, may apply. This section addresses the way coverage applies when more than one coverage could apply to a claim. However, the main reason is to specify that different carriers or self-insurers pay losses in equal shares.

Example: John was seriously injured in an accident. Coverage is available from two insurance companies and a self-insurance plan. Company C insurance company is subject to a $100,000 limit but the other carriers are not limited. The amount of John’s claims totals $1,250,000 over his lifetime and is paid as follows:

Company

Initial Amount

Remaining Amount

Total Paid

A

$100,000

$475,000

$575,000

B

$100,000

$475,000

$575,000

C

$100,000

0

$100,000

Total

$300,000

$950,000

$1,250,000

Employers in all states must either purchase insurance to cover their full liability or qualify as self-insurers by meeting certain specific financial requirements. A few large and financially stable employers may be completely self-insured but most also purchase excess coverage, either voluntarily or as part of having to qualify for self-insurance. Excess coverage is similar to other kinds of excess liability insurance. It pays the amount that exceeds a certain monetary threshold, such as a deductible or retention amount. This excess may apply as specific excess on a specific loss or as aggregate excess for the total of losses that occur during the policy period.

F. Payments You Must Make

The insurance company does not pay on behalf of the named any amounts beyond the benefits described in the workers compensation law that applies. Examples of such costs that the company does not pay are the following:

1. That result from the named insured engaging in serious and intentional misconduct

2. Imposed because the named insured employed an individual whom it was not legally permitted to employ. This applies only when such employment was done so with the named insured’s knowledge.

3. Amounts it must pay because it did not comply with health or safety regulations

4. That result from violating a workers compensation law with respect to discharging, coercing, or in any way discriminating against any employee

In some cases the insurance company may pay these amounts when it settles a claim. In those cases, the named insured must reimburse the insurance company.

Example: Happy Valley Printers employed several underage teenagers to work in its ancient plant. One of the teens sustained a serious injury to his arm when an overheated machine broke down on one particularly hectic day. Happy Valley promptly reported the loss, submitted the claim, and was honest about the worker’s age and the details of the accident. A provision in the state's workers compensation law provided for payments that exceed regular benefits for underage workers and Happy Valley’s carrier had to make the additional payments. Happy Valley then had to reimburse the carrier for those additional payments because it violated state hiring laws.

Related Article: Employed Minors and Workers Compensation Insurance

G. Recovery from Others

The insurance company has the named insured's rights of recovery against those responsible for an injury. It also has the rights of any party entitled to benefits under this insurance to recover payments it paid from those liable from the injury that resulted in those payments. The named insured must do everything possible and necessary to protect those rights and help the insurance company enforce them.

Notes:

This is similar to the rights of recovery provisions in other coverage forms and policies. Most workers compensation laws state that the employer is entitled to the employee's rights of recovery against third parties to the extent of the compensation it owes. Under this provision, the employee's rights of recovery against others pass to the employer by the workers compensation act and, in turn, pass to the insurance company.

Example: Zachary works for Rapunzel, LLC. While he is driving to an appointment, the car Kimberly drives strikes his car and seriously injures his left hand. Rapunzel’s worker’s compensation carrier, Great Job Mutual, pays for Zachary’s injuries according to its policy terms. Great Job Mutual then assumes all of Rapunzel and Zachary’s rights of recovery against Kimberly to recover the payments it made and may continue to make.

The insurance company obtains the employee's rights of recovery against third parties to the extent of the benefits it paid. WC 00 03 13–Waiver of Our Right to Recover from Others Endorsement waives the company's right of subrogation against designated third parties responsible for an injury. The endorsement schedule is used to list the persons or organizations that the insurance company agrees to not subrogate against.

Related Article: Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy Available Endorsements and Their Uses

Related Court Case: Insurer’s Recovery under Lien Capped at Claimant’s Net Recovery

H. Statutory Provisions

This section contains six statements that apply to the insured employer as required by law in the states where coverage is provided.

1. The insurance company is considered to have received notice of an injury to an employee at the same time that the named insured received it.

2. The named insured's bankruptcy, insolvency, or default does not relieve the insurance company of its duties when a covered injury occurs.

3. The insurance company’s responsibility is to pay benefits to any person entitled to them. Such persons or an agency authorized by law may enforce those duties against the named insured, the insurance company, or both.

4. With respect to the workers compensation law(s) that apply, jurisdiction over the insurance company is treated the same as jurisdiction over the named insured. The company is obligated to the same decisions made based on that law against the named insured, subject to policy provisions that do not conflict with the law.

5. This policy automatically conforms to any part of any workers compensation law that applies to the following:

·       Benefits that this insurance pays

·       Special taxes, payments made to security funds or other special funds, and assessments that the law requires the company to pay

6. Any portion of the policy that conflicts or is at odds with the workers compensation law in a given state is automatically changed to conform to and comply with that state’s law.

Nothing in any of these statements relieves the named insured of its duties under this policy.

Note: Only those provisions that laws in a given state require are made part of the policy and only with respect to the coverage that applies in that state. For example, the right of "direct action" against the company under item 3. above does not apply in any state that does not have a direct action statute.

PART TWO–EMPLOYERS LIABILITY INSURANCE

Part Two provides Employers Liability Insurance as opposed to Part One that provides Workers Compensation Insurance. The main difference between the two is that Part One applies to statutory benefits the named insured must pay. Part Two applies to common or tort law or other damages for which the named insured is liable.

A. How This Insurance Applies

Employers liability insurance is coverage for bodily injury by accident or bodily injury by disease, including death that results from either. It is subject to five conditions:

1. The employee's bodily injury must arise from and be in the course of employment by the named insured.

2. The work the employee performs at the time he or she incurs bodily injury does not have to take place in a state or territory listed in Item 3. A. on the Information Page. However, that employee's employment must be considered necessary or incidental to the named insured’s work at a location within such a listed state or territory.

3. Coverage for bodily injury by accident requires that the bodily injury take place during the policy term.

4. Coverage for bodily injury by disease requires that the conditions that relate to the named insured's employment must cause or aggravate the disease. The employee's last day of exposure to the conditions that cause or aggravate the bodily injury caused by disease must be during the policy term.

5. Suits or legal action against the named insured for bodily injury by accident or disease must be brought in the United States of America, its territories or possessions, or Canada.

B. We Will Pay

The insurance company pays all amounts the named insured must legally pay as damages because of bodily injury to its employees that this insurance covers. Where the law permits recovery for such damages, the company is responsible for all of the following damages:

1. An employee of the named insured is injured and that employee makes a claim against a third party. That third party then pursues actions against the named insured to recover for that employee’s claim.

Note: This is commonly referred to as a "third party over" claim made against the employer by a third party an injured employee sues.

Example: Mike was an employee of MasonryIsUs and was injured on a construction site. While carrying some hollow concrete block, he tripped over some pipes that fell from a pile of pipes that employees of Bartleby Plumbing improperly stacked. He was entitled to both workers compensation benefits from MasonryIsUs and to damages from Bartleby. If he sued Bartleby and it, in turn, sued (or "impleaded") the insured employer for contribution or indemnification, MasonryIsUs' Employers Liability coverage would apply.

2. Care and loss of services

Note: If the employee makes a claim under items 1 or 4 of this item, a separate claim may be made by a family member for his or her care and loss of services. This item would pay for that claim.

3. Consequential bodily injury to the injured employee’s brother, sister, parent, child, or spouse. This is subject to a requirement that the damages are the direct consequence of a bodily injury incident that arises from and occurs during the course of that employee’s employment by the named insured.

If an employee makes a claim under items 1. or 4. of this section, a family member can make a separate claim for consequential injuries that relate to the employee’s injuries.

4. Because of bodily injury to the named insured's employee that arises from and in the course of employment and is claimed against the named insured in a different capacity than as an employer

Note: Employers liability also covers damages an employer owes under the so-called "dual capacity" doctrine. It states that an employer may have two different legal personalities for purposes of liability to an employee.

Example: Joe worked for Sturdy Steel Doors, a steel door manufacturer. He was welding a door when one of its spring-loaded hinges snapped open, struck, and seriously injured his arm. When the hinge was inspected, it was determined that the spring-loaded component of the hinge did not have the proper retaining pin to hold it in place. Sturdy Steel Doors may be liable for Joe’s injury under products liability because it manufactured the defective hinge.

Notes:

This is the indemnity provision of Part Two. The company pays all amounts the insured employer is legally responsible for as damages because of bodily injury that this policy covers. "Damages" is the key word. Employers liability insurance is coverage against torts or other liability for damages. This contrasts with the employer's statutory liability for workers compensation benefits under Part One. "Damages" is not a defined term but the following is a generally accepted legal meaning from Black's Law Dictionary:

"A pecuniary (financial) compensation or indemnity, which may be recovered in the courts by any person who has suffered loss, detriment, or injury, whether to his person, property, or rights, through the unlawful act or omission or negligence of another."

The kinds of damages listed above are not meant to be inclusive. They simply illustrate the primary categories where these claims normally fall.

Part Two does not cover true no-fault workers compensation laws, like the United States Longshore and Harbor Workers Compensation Act (USL&HWCA) because they compensate on a no-fault basis. Part One may provide coverage for USL&HWCA, Federal Black Lung, and other federal laws by endorsing the policy to amend its language to include a federal law or laws in addition to the applicable state or territory laws listed under Item 3. A.

C. Exclusions

Coverage does not apply to the following:

1. Any liability assumed under a contract. However, this does not apply to warranties that the named insured will perform its work in a workmanlike way.

2. Any punitive or exemplary damages awarded because of bodily injury to a person whose employment violates the law

3. Any bodily injury to a person whose employment violates the law if the named insured or any of its executive officers actually knew that the employment was unlawful

4. Obligations that workers compensation, occupational disease, unemployment compensation, disability benefits, or any similar laws impose

Note: This exclusion removes all obligations under workers compensation or similar laws from Part Two because either Part One covers them or they are not covered at all. However, a specific employee not covered under a workers compensation law may sue the employer for damages. Part Two may cover that claim. For example, workers compensation laws do not usually apply to agricultural and domestic workers.

Related Article: Domestic Workers, Farm Workers, and Workers Compensation Insurance

5. Any bodily injury the named insured intentionally causes or aggravates

Note: This important exclusion is similar to corresponding exclusions in other liability coverage forms and policies. It also raises at least two points that vary in importance from state to state, depending on the state’s law. First, most states except intentional injury by the employer from the exclusive remedy doctrine. Since the exception applies to Part One, this exclusion is needed in Part Two to exclude coverage for these types of injuries. Second, the exclusion applies to the employer but not to co-workers. In most states, the employer is not responsible for an employee’s intentional torts.

Related Court Case: Co-worker’s Punch Resulted in Accidental and Compensable Injuries

6. Bodily injury that occurs outside the United States of America, its territories or possessions, and Canada. However, coverage does apply to bodily injury that citizens or residents of the United States of America or Canada sustain while temporarily outside either of these countries.

7. Any damages due to the named insured coercing, criticizing, demoting, evaluating, reassigning, disciplining, defaming, harassing, humiliating, terminating, or discriminating against any employee. This also applies to damages that result from any of the named insured's personnel practices, policies, acts, or omissions.

Example: Sara is Pete’s administrative assistant. Pete has a bad temper. Whenever he becomes angry at anyone, he yells at Sara, humiliates her in front of her co-workers and outsiders, and defames her abilities and character. She begins to suffer high blood pressure, anxiety attacks, and other stress related issues but cannot quit her job due to economic realities. She has a serious stroke and her family sues Pete. The workers compensation policy does not provide coverage in this case because of Pete’s actions towards Sara.

8. Bodily injury to persons working subject to the following Acts:

  • The United States Longshore and Harbor Workers Compensation Act
  • The Defense Base Act
  • The Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act
  • The Nonappropriated Fund Instrumentalities Act
  • The Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act

WC 00 00 00 B does not have the reference to "of 1969" that was in WC 00 00 00 A.

This exclusion also applies to any other federal workers or workmen's compensation law, any other federal occupational disease law, and any amendments to any of these laws.

Note: This exclusion excludes coverage under specifically listed federal acts and clarifies policy language.

Related Articles:

The United States Longshore and Harbor Workers Compensation Act (USL&HWCA)

The Defense Base Act

The Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act

The Nonappropriated Fund Instrumentalities Act

The Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act

9. Bodily injury to persons who work subject to the Federal Employers' Liability Act. This exclusion also applies to any other federal law that obligates employers to pay damages to employees for bodily injury due to or in the course of their employment. This also includes any amendments to those laws.

Related Article: The Federal Employers' Liability Act (FELA) of 1908

10. Bodily injury to crewmembers or the master of any vessel

11. Fines or penalties required due to violating any federal or state law

12. Damages that should be paid under the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act. This also includes damages under any other federal law that awards damages for violating those laws or regulations and any amendments to those laws.

Related Article: The Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act (MSAWPA)

D. We Will Defend

The insurance company has both the right and the duty to defend any claim, suit, or other legal action for covered damages that others bring against the named insured. It does so at its own expense. It also has the right to investigate and settle any claim, suit, or other legal action. However, it does not have a duty to defend any legal action against the named insured that this policy excludes. It also does not have a duty to defend or continue to defend after it pays the limit of insurance that applies.

Notes:

This provision is similar to those in most other liability coverage forms and policies and Part One of this policy. Some coverage forms and policies have provisions for the right to defend but not the duty to do so. This and similar defense provisions obligate the insurance company to retain and pay competent legal counsel to properly represent the named insured in lawsuits, administrative or judicial proceedings, and appeals. The company selects legal counsel it deems appropriate as part of its right to defend and has the right to investigate and settle claims. It assumes unlimited defense costs.

Like similar provisions in other liability coverage forms and policies, the company's duty to defend is broader than its duty to indemnify. Unless the allegations of a claim clearly remove it from coverage, the company must defend until it determines the fact or issue that excludes coverage.

Employers liability insurance is subject to limits of liability as G. Limits of Liability under Part Two analyzed below describes. As a result, this section specifies that the company's duty to defend ends when the limits of insurance are used up. Defense costs are not included in determining when the appropriate limit is used up.

E. We Will Also Pay

The insurance company also pays a number of costs and expenses as part of a claim, suit, or legal action it defends in addition to other amounts it pays. They include the following:

1. All reasonable expenses the named insured incurs at the company's request. However, this does not include loss of earnings.

2. Premiums for bonds to release attachments or for appeal bonds, up to amounts that this insurance pays

3. Costs of litigation assessed against the named insured

4. Interest on judgments as the law requires. However, this is only until the insurance company offers to pay the amount due.

5. Any and all expenses the insurance company incurs that relate to a claim, suit, or action

F. Other Insurance

More than one insurance company may be responsible for a particular loss. In that case, this insurance company does not pay more than its proportion or share of costs and benefits covered by all available sources. The other sources may be other insurance companies or self-insurance. All sources must contribute equally until the loss is paid. If the limits of any other insurance policy or self-insurance are used up, all remaining insurance pays in equal shares until the loss is completely paid.

Notes:

This section primarily addresses payments by different insurance based on equal shares. The limits of liability referred to may occur in cases where an employer has a self-insured retention up to a certain amount and excess insurance above that amount.

The last sentence states that certain insurance or self-insurance may be used up. This refers to payments that equal the available limit of liability, funds not available due to a carrier's insolvency, or for some other reason. In these cases, any remaining insurance contributes to the loss in equal shares.

G. Limits of Liability

The insurance company's obligation to pay for damages does not exceed the limits of liability under Item 3. B. on the Information Page. They apply as follows:

1. The Bodily Injury by Accident–each accident limit on the Information Page is the most paid for all covered damages due to bodily injury to one or more employees as a result of any one accident.

Note: Disease is not bodily injury by accident unless it is a direct result of bodily injury by accident.

2. The Bodily Injury by Disease–policy limit on the Information Page is the most paid for all covered damages due to bodily injury by disease. This applies regardless of the number of employees who sustain bodily injury by disease. The Bodily Injury by Disease–each employee limit on the Information Page is the most paid for all covered damages due to bodily injury by disease to any one employee. Bodily injury by disease does not include disease that is a direct result of a bodily injury by accident.

3. The insurance company does not pay any claims for damages after the limit of insurance that applies is used up paying claims.

Note: Rule 3, Item 14 of the Basic Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance provides the following standard limits of liability for these coverages:

  • $100,000 Bodily Injury by Accident–each accident
  • $500,000 Bodily Injury by Disease–policy limit
  • $100,000 Bodily Injury by Disease–each employee

These standard limits can be increased to higher limits for the additional percentage premium charges in the rules section.

Example: Barney throws an appreciation party for his 25 employees and their families. He and his wife prepare the food and bring it to the office. Right after lunch, fifteen employees become violently ill and one dies. The subsequent investigation reveals that Barney mistakenly added caustic cleanser to the gravy instead of flour. When the employees sue him for their injuries, his employers liability is limited to $100,000 Bodily Injury by Accident limit for all injuries sustained. If it had been a disease instead of an accident, the $500,000 policy limit would have applied, subject to $100,000 for each employee.

Note: Additional or excess employers liability insurance can be provided under excess or umbrella policies written separately from the Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy. A few states require unlimited employers liability insurance and special endorsements are available to meet those requirements.

H. Recovery from Others

The insurance company has the named insured's rights to recover its payments made from any party liable for the injury. The named insured must do everything possible and necessary to protect those rights and help the insurance company enforce them.

Notes:

Similar to the same provision in G. Recovery from Others under Part One, this is the subrogation provision that applies to employers liability. The primary difference between the two is that this one does not give the company the named insured's employee's rights of recovery. It is limited to only giving the named insured's rights against third parties. This difference is necessary because the insurance company can acquire the named insured's rights only through the insurance policy.

WC 00 03 13–Waiver of Our Right to Recover from Others Endorsement waives the company's right of subrogation against designated third parties responsible for an injury. The endorsement schedule is used to list the persons or organizations that the insurance company will not subrogate against.

Related Article: Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy Available Endorsements and Their Uses

I. Actions against Us

The insurance company cannot be sued or have other legal action brought against it unless both of the following apply:

1. The named insured has complied with all policy terms and conditions.

2. A trial and final judgment determined the amount the named insured owes or the insurance company agreed with the amount owed.

No party has the right to name the insurance company as a defendant in a legal action brought against the named insured to determine its liability. In addition, the insurance company's obligations do not change if the named insured or its estate becomes bankrupt or insolvent.

Note: This provision is the opposite of the "direct action" provision described in H. Statutory Provisions under Part One. In other words, it specifically excludes the right of direct action against the company until these requirements are met.

PART THREE–OTHER STATES INSURANCE

A. How This Insurance Applies

1. Other states insurance applies only if there are one or more states listed under Item 3. C. on the Information Page.

Note: This clarifies that if the named insured initiates work or operations in any states listed under Item 3. C. on the Information Page, coverage applies as though that state was listed under Item 3. A. on the Information Page. This includes even minimal contacts that might trigger that state's workers compensation law.

2. If the named insured initiates work or operations in any state listed under Item 3. C. on the Information Page after the policy effective date and there is no other coverage for that state, all policy provisions apply as if the state was listed under Item 3. A. on the Information Page.

Note: Coverage under Part Three is not intended to apply to ongoing operations. There is no premium charge, regardless of the extent of the insured's known operations or the number of states involved. A payroll or other premium basis is available only if the named insured actually initiates work or operations in those states. In those cases, the appropriate state rate(s) apply to the premium basis that actually develops during the policy period.

3. The insurance company reimburses the named insured for benefits that state’s workers compensation laws require in cases where it is not allowed to pay benefits directly to injured persons entitled to them.

Note: The named insured must tell the insurance company any time it initiates work or operations in a state not listed under Item 3. A. on the Information Page. This part lets the insurance company that is not authorized to pay workers compensation benefits to an injured employee in a given state pay them indirectly through the employer.

Related Court Case: Coverage Applied to Employee Working Solely at Out-of State Location

4. Coverage does not apply in states and in cases where the named insured has work in any state not listed under Item 3. A. on the Information Page as of the effective date. However, there is a 30-day grace period for the named insured to notify the insurance company about the work.

Note: This provision strengthens the notification requirement so that the company can more accurately determine the extent of the coverage it provides. Coverage does not apply to that state if the named insured does not notify the company on a timely basis.

B. Notice

The named insured must immediately notify the insurance company of any work or operations it begins in any state listed under Item 3.C. on the Information Page.

Notes:

When this occurs, the company endorses the policy to change that state to a state listed under item 3. A. and uses premium audit or other methods to determine a premium basis for it.

Part Three is a feature unique to the Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy. The insured employer has coverage available for possible workers compensation exposures in states where it does not now have or expect operations or work. It relates specifically to the "extraterritorial" effect of most state workers compensation laws. These laws apply (or are interpreted to apply) to work-related accidents that occur in both the state in question as well as to accidents that occur elsewhere under certain circumstances as follows:

  • The contract of hire was made within the state
  • The employment was primarily localized within the state
  • Even if the injured employee simply resides in the state

Example: An employer has operations in only New York State but sends an employee to Indiana on business. While performing his job in the Hoosier State, the employee sustains serious bodily injury. The employee may be entitled to claim benefits under the Indiana Workers Compensation Law.

On the other hand, an employee working for a California employer injured in an accident in California may be able to assert a claim under the New York Workers Compensation Law if he or she was hired in New York State. As a result, most employers that have employment contracts of any kind in various states may need coverage for possible workers compensation exposures in those states.

PART FOUR–YOUR DUTIES IF INJURY OCCURS

The named insured must immediately report any injury that occurs that this insurance might cover to the insurance company. However, the obligations do not end there.

Related Court Case: How Late Is Too Late?

The following are other required duties:

1. Provide or arrange for immediate medical care and any required services but only as the workers compensation law of the state where the injury takes place requires.

2. Provide the insurance company or the insurance agent the names and addresses of the injured person or persons and the same information for any witnesses to the injury. This is in addition to other information the company may need.

3. Promptly give the insurance company originals of all notices, demands, and any other legal papers that relate to an injury, claim, suit, or other legal proceeding.

4. Cooperate with and help the insurance company investigate, settle, or defend any claim, suit, or legal proceeding to the extent that it requests.

Note: There is no limit on the number of times the company may request cooperation and assistance. However, the frequency should not overly burden either party.

5. Do not do anything after an injury or claim occurs that interferes with or disrupts the insurance company's ability or rights to recover from others that/who might be liable for the loss.

6. Do not make any voluntary payments, assume any obligations, or incur any expenses without the insurance company's written approval. Doing so is at the named insured's cost and the company is not required to reimburse it for any unauthorized payments it made.

Note: These duties apply to any loss, injury, accident, or damages that occur and that Part One, Part Two, or Part Three cover.

Related Court Case: Notice to Workers Compensation Department Also Held to be Notice to General Liability Department

PART FIVE–PREMIUM

This Part describes how and when premium is calculated, when it is paid, and how cancellation affects premium. It also imposes record-keeping requirements on the named insured and gives the carrier the right to inspect and audit the named insured's records that relate to the policy.

Related Article: Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy Rating Considerations

Related Court Case: Carrier Can Change Classification Code and Charge Increased Premium Retrospectively

A. Our Manuals

The insurance company determines the premium charge based on its manuals of rules, rates, rating plans, codes, and classifications. It can change its manuals and apply those changes to this policy if it is authorized by law or by a government agency charged with regulating this insurance coverage.

Notes:

As used in this provision, "manuals" has a very specific meaning. Most of the time, the company's manuals of rules, rates, rating plans, codes, and classifications correspond to the manuals NCCI files with the appropriate insurance regulatory authorities on behalf of its member companies in its capacity as a licensed rating or advisory organization. These manuals include the following:

  • The Basic Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance

This manual includes the rules, manual rates or loss costs, rating plans and values, codes, classifications, and premium discounts for all NCCI states. The manual rates or loss costs may be only advisory in states where NCCI is an advisory organization and may not actually be adopted by any given insurance company.

  • The Experience Rating Plan Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance

This manual describes and details how the mandatory experience rating plan works. With it, the named insured's past loss experience is used to calculate a premium modification factor that either increases or decreases the manual premium to the final net premium charged for the current policy period. It also includes rules that govern how to apply the experience modification, the formula to calculate the experience modification, and the numerical values and factors that formula uses.

Related Article: Experience Rating in Workers Compensation Insurance

  • The Retrospective Rating Plan Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance

This manual describes and details how the various optional rating plans that modify the premium for a given policy period work. These plans can be applied in addition to experience rating, based on the named insured's actual loss experience during that policy period.

As stated above, NCCI prepares and files manuals on behalf of its member companies in states where it is the authorized rating or advisory organization. In a few states, independent rating bureaus prepare and file manuals similar to the NCCI manuals where they are the authorized rating organization. In addition, individual insurance companies may be authorized or required to file their own rates or other manuals in certain states. Here, the reference in the policy means the individual insurance company's manual or manuals. From a strictly legal standpoint, the effect of Part Five A. is to incorporate by reference the various manuals into the insurance policy.

The premium provision resembles Part One in that it effectively incorporates the provisions of the various state workers compensation laws into the policy. Manuals are subject to periodic revisions and most states revise rates or loss costs annually. The second sentence of this provision provides that manual changes authorized by law or by a regulatory agency apply to the policy. Rule 1. F. in the Basic Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance explains how to handle classification changes or corrections.

Rule changes usually apply to only policies issued or renewed on or after the effective date of the rule change. On the other hand, changes in manual rates or loss costs may apply to existing policies based on the terms of the rate filing that applies and its approval.

In most cases, rate changes due to changes in the benefit provisions of the state workers compensation law are applied to existing policies on a pro rata basis as of the effective date of the rate change. WC 00 04 04–Pending Rate Change Endorsement and WC 00 04 07–Rate Change Endorsement are the two standard endorsements used with these types of rate changes.

Related Article: Anniversary Rating Date Endorsement

B. Classifications

This provision states that the rate and premium bases for certain business or work classifications are entered under Item 4. on the Information Page. Classifications are based on descriptions the named insured provides for the policy period. Classifications may also be based on the insurance company's (or by others that act on its behalf) inspections of the operations. If the exposures should be classified differently, the insurance company endorses the proper classifications, rates, and premium bases to the policy.

Related Article: WC 00 00 01 A–Information Page–Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance Policy

Notes:

It is not always possible to accurately predict the kinds of work the named insured will do during the policy period. However, the insurance company usually assumes all of the named insured's workers compensation exposures during the policy period. As a result, it must estimate the proper classifications that apply at inception. It later confirms or revises those estimates based on information it receives during or after the policy period or based on a physical audit of the named insured's books and records.

The named insured's business or operations may change during the policy period or the original premium estimates may not be accurate. In that case, this provision gives the insurance company the right to make any changes necessary that reflect the actual exposures. This provision can be enforced and the ability to do so is well established through previous precedent and court decisions.

C. Remuneration

The estimated or deposit premium for each work classification is calculated by multiplying the premium basis by the rate for the code and classification that applies. Remuneration or payroll is the usual premium basis and includes all payroll and remuneration paid during the policy period. The remuneration for services falls into two categories:

1. All officers and employees engaged in the work that the policy covers

2. Other persons engaged in work that could make the insurance company liable under the policy's workers compensation part. The contract price for their services and materials can be used as the premium basis if the named insured does not have payroll records for these persons. However, this paragraph does not apply if the named insured proves that the employers of these persons had proper workers compensation coverage in place on them for the work performed.

Related Article: Workers Compensation Independent Contractor Status

Related Court Cases:

Contractor Was an Employee Rather than an Employer

Independent Trucker Was Not a Statutory Owner-Operator

Newspaper Delivery Persons Were Employees, Not Independent Contractors

Notes:

In most cases, the premium for each classification is usually based on payroll multiplied by a rate per $100 of payroll. However, payroll or remuneration is not always the premium basis. For example, the premium charge for taxi companies in some states is based on an assumed amount of remuneration per cab driver, not on the actual remuneration received. In another example, domestic servants are charged for on a "per capita" basis, such as $500 per employee per year.

Payroll is the most common premium basis. As a result, the NCCI Basic Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance thoroughly defines "remuneration." It includes all payroll and any other type of remuneration either paid or that becomes payable during the policy period for business services rendered. It usually includes commissions, bonuses, and non-cash compensation for services but does not include tips, group insurance contributions, or severance pay. This provision also states that premium is usually based on all officers and employees whose work is part of the operations the policy covers that is subject to the workers compensation law. In some cases, executive officers of a corporation may elect to opt out of or not be subject to the workers compensation law.

This provision also states that the premium basis includes remuneration paid to "other persons engaged in work" that could lead to a covered workers compensation loss. Most workers compensation laws make a contractor liable for compensation payments to injured employees of uninsured subcontractors. This provision details what the insurance company should use to charge additional premium for the additional exposures that uninsured subcontractors cause.

Proof of workers compensation coverage usually means a certificate of workers compensation insurance or other evidence of workers compensation coverage for the subcontractor's employees. This provision also lets the insurance company charge a premium based on the contract price for the services and materials uninsured subcontractors provide if their actual payroll records are not available.

Related Article: Certificates of Insurance and Workers Compensation Insurance

D. Premium Payments

The named insured pays the premium when it is due, even if all or part of a workers compensation law is invalid.

Notes:

This acknowledges the possibility that certain provisions of workers compensation laws may be unconstitutional under the terms of a state constitution or the United States Constitution. Some early workers compensation statutes were declared unconstitutional because they allowed taking an employer’s property without "due process" or deprived the parties of the right to a jury trial, among other reasons.

Most state workers compensation laws are not subject to attack on these constitutional grounds today. However, this provision acknowledges that certain provisions of a workers compensation law may be invalid on constitutional or other grounds. The "full faith and credit" clause of the United States Constitution (Art. IV, Sec. 1) is an area of continuing concern. It requires that a state have a "legitimate interest" in a compensable injury if another state is to enforce or recognize its law.

E. Final Premium

The premium on the Information Page, schedules, and endorsements is estimated. The final premium is determined after the policy expires by using the actual payroll, the correct classifications, and rates that apply to the operations performed or work done. If the final premium calculated is more than the estimated premium, the insured pays the insurance company the difference. If the final premium calculated is less, the insurance company returns the excess to the named insured, subject to the highest minimum premium for the classifications that applies.

If the policy is cancelled, the final premium is determined in one of two ways:

1. If the company cancels, the final premium is pro rata, based on the amount of time the policy was in force but not less than the pro rata share of the minimum premium.

2. If the named insured cancels, the final premium is more than pro rata. It is based on the time the policy was in force, increased by the short rate cancellation table and procedures. In this case, the final premium is not less than the minimum premium.

Notes:

This provision complements B. Classifications under Part Five. It states that the premium on the Information Page or elsewhere is only an estimate. It also states that the actual premium the named insured pays during the policy period is the basis used to calculate the final premium. It emphasizes that the proper classifications and rates are applied to that premium basis to produce the final premium.

Once the final premium is determined, the policy provides for a final payment by either the named insured or the insurance company. This depends on amounts previously paid so that the premium paid for the policy equals the final premium. If the policy is cancelled before the expiration date, this provision states that the final premium will be calculated "pro rata" if the company cancels and "short rate" if the named insured cancels.

The rules of the Basic Manual for Workers Compensation and Employers Liability Insurance describe pro rata and short rate premium refunds. Pro rata cancellation charges the proportionate premium for each day of coverage. Short rate cancellation involves an increased charge to the named insured. Short rate cancellation allows the company to recoup part of its policy writing, inspection, and acquisition costs that accompany initial policy issuance.

F. Records

The named insured must keep and maintain records that provide the information the insurance company needs to calculate the final premium. The named insured must give the insurance company copies of those records when it asks for them.

Note: These are primarily payroll records. This provision is similar to the records condition in most insurance coverage forms and policies.

G. Audit

The named insured must let the insurance company examine and audit all records that relate to this policy. Ledgers, journals, registers, vouchers, contracts, tax reports, payroll and disbursement records, and programs that store and retrieve data are examples of the records that may be required but it is not limited to only these. Records may be in hard copy or electronic data form. Access to these records is for audit purposes and to determine the final premium.

Premium audits are usually done during regular business hours during the policy period and within three years after the policy expires. The insurance company uses information obtained from the audit to determine the final policy premium. The rights of the insurance company under this provision also apply to insurance rate service organizations.

Note: The three-year period after expiration allows audits of smaller policies in cases where annual audits are not economically practical. The reference to insurance rate service organizations gives NCCI or other independent rate service organizations the opportunity to participate in audits and to determine that the classifications used in the policy are correct.

PART SIX–CONDITIONS

A. Inspection

The insurance company has the right to inspect workplaces at any time but it is not obligated to do so. These are not safety inspections. They relate to only the insurability of the workplace(s) and the premium(s) charged. The company may provide reports on the conditions it finds to the named insured and recommend changes to make. These inspections are not intended to serve the same purpose as a person with the duty to provide for the health or safety of the named insured's employees or the public. For this reason, the company does not warrant that the named insured's workplaces are safe or healthful or that they meet applicable laws, codes, regulations, or standards. The insurance company’s rights under this provision also apply to insurance rate service organizations.

Note: The disclaimer provisions in this condition are similar to those in other insurance coverage forms and policies. It relieves the insurance company of any liability that might result from its performing an inspection. The inspections are for the company's use, not the named insured's.

B. Long-Term Policy

The insurance company may issue a policy with a term of more than one year and 16 days. In that case, all policy provisions apply as if a new policy is issued on each annual anniversary that the policy is in effect.

Note: A policy may be issued for any length of time up to three years. A policy with a term of less than one year and 16 days is treated as a single year policy. Otherwise, the policy period is divided into twelve-month units and the first or last unit of less than twelve months is treated as a short-term policy. Each such unit is subject to provisions such as minimum premium, short rate cancellation, etc.

C. Transfer of Your Rights and Duties

The named insured may not transfer its rights or duties under this policy without the insurance company's written consent. If an insured is an individual person and dies, and the insurance company is notified of it within 30 days after the date of death, it treats the deceased insured's legal representative as the insured.

Note: From the company's point of view, restricting the ability to assign rights and duties is necessary because the nature or extent of the risk could change dramatically when a transfer or assignment occurs. Most other insurance coverage forms and policies have similar provisions.

D. Cancellation

Either the named insured or the insurance company may cancel the policy. Four conditions make up this provision.

1. The named insured may cancel the policy by mailing or delivering written notice to the insurance company in advance of the requested cancellation date stated in the notice.

2. The insurance company may cancel the policy by mailing or delivering at least ten days’ advance written notice of the cancellation effective date. Mailing the notice to the named insured at the mailing address under Item 1. on the Information Page is sufficient to prove notice.

3. Coverage ends on the date and at the hour stated in the notice of cancellation the insurance company issues.

4. Cancellation provisions may conflict with laws that affect cancellation of insurance policies. In that case, the policy is amended to conform to and comply with that law.

Notes:

The named insured and the insurance company both have the right to cancel the policy. This provision does not specify the reasons the company can cancel. However, most state laws require basing its cancellation on certain reasons, such as nonpayment of premium, misrepresentation, or substantial changes in the risk. On the other hand, the named insured does not have to state a reason to cancel.

This provision also requires that the insurance company give at least a ten day notice before the cancellation takes effect. Most state laws require longer periods and those longer periods apply automatically as this subsection provides. Standard state-specific endorsements contain the cancellation notice period and other cancellation requirements.

E. Sole Representative

The first named insured under Item 1. on the Information Page acts on behalf of all insureds with respect to any policy changes, premiums, and notices of cancellation.

Note: More than one corporation or entity may be insured under a single policy if there is substantially common majority ownership. This policy provision is necessary when there are two or more insureds because only one legal entity usually carries out transactions with the company at any one time. The first named insured is responsible for policy maintenance issues like paying premiums and audits, requesting changes or endorsements, receiving return premiums, and giving or receiving notice of cancellation.