Cole Cooper, while riding his motorcycle, struck a trailer that had been left on the side of the road. Cole sued the trailer owner, Rick's Blacktop & Paving Company, who turned the case over to Grinnell Mutual Reinsurance Company who provided both commercial general liability coverage and business auto coverage for Rick's. Grinnell refused to provide coverage under either policy.
Rick's challenged the decision and when he didn't like the first ruling appealed it to a higher court.
Click here to see how the courts ruled.