Volume 148

APRIL 2019

Return to main screen

PF&M ANALYSIS:

BP 00 03–BUSINESSOWNERS COVERAGE FORM ANALYSIS

G. OPTIONAL COVERAGES

Optional Coverages do not apply unless there is a limit for them on the declarations. They are subject to the property coverage terms and conditions, except for and/or as stated below.

3. Employee Dishonesty (07 13 change)

a. The insurance company pays for direct loss of business personal property and money and securities due to dishonest acts its employees commit, whether they act alone or collude with others to do so. However, it does not include actions by the named insured or a partner. In order for coverage to apply, the act must intend to cause the named insured to sustain a loss and also to benefit the employee, other persons, or other organizations.

Note: The term employee as used in this optional coverage is broad. It is not defined within the Definition section but is defined later in this optional coverage.

b. There is no coverage for loss or damage:

·         Due to dishonest acts by the named insured, its partners, or members, whether they act alone or collude to do so

·         For dishonest acts by managers or directors who act alone or who collude with others. Such acts are excluded while they are providing a service for the named insured or are performing a service for others.

·          For dishonest acts of employees, except as a. above provides, while in collusion, acting alone, or while they are performing for the named insured or performing services for others.

·         If the only proof that a loss occurred is an inventory or a profit and loss calculation

·         (07 13 addition) Losses an employee causes if both of the following apply:

o    The employee committed a dishonest act or theft prior to the inception date of this policy

o    Any of the named insured’s partners, members, managers, officers, directors, or trustees knew about that employee’s prior dishonest act or theft. This item does not apply if the individual who knew about the incident was in collusion with the employee.

c. The most paid in a single occurrence is the Employee Dishonesty Limit of Insurance on the declarations.

d. Loss or damage caused by one or more persons or that involves a single act or a series of acts is considered a single occurrence.

e. If the current policy and a previously terminated or cancelled policy that the same or an affiliated insurance company issued to the named insured both cover a loss, the amount paid is limited to the largest amount that any policy provided, regardless of the number of years it was in effect. Limits are not cumulative from year to year.

Note: This provision eliminates stacking limits from two or more policies due to a series of acts.

 

Example: Floyd’s Meat Market has the best steaks in town. Ernie is the head butcher and takes steaks home with him at least once a week for over ten years but never tells Floyd. Ernie finally recognizes the error of his ways and confesses to Floyd. Floyd suddenly realizes that Ernie has stolen $6,000 worth of steaks in each of the past ten years. His claim is for $60,000 since he has been with the same company the whole time. The loss is capped at $10,000 because the Employee Dishonesty Limit of Insurance is $10,000.

http://rnc-advantageplus.com/rnc-advantageplus/pfm/100/192_0402_files/image045.jpg

 

f. This coverage is cancelled with respect to a specific employee as soon as the named insured or one or more of its partners, members, managers, officers, or directors who are not in collusion with the employee become aware of dishonest acts the employee committed before or after he or she was hired.

 

Example: Floyd at Floyd’s Meat Market really likes Ernie and wants to keep him as an employee. The policy permits this but coverage does not apply to Ernie if he commits any other dishonest acts. Even if Floyd did not report Ernie’s actions, Ernie is not covered in the future because Floyd knew about the situation.

 

g. Loss must be sustained during the policy period and discovered not later than one year after the end of the policy period.

h. If the named insured had a covered loss in a previous policy period but did not discover it until after its discovery period expired, the current policy covers the loss as long as there was no break in coverage from the previous policy and the current policy would have covered the loss or damage if it was in effect at the time of loss.

 

Example: The policy for John’s Pizza and Deli has been in force continuously since the business started ten years ago. The policy dates are 01/01 to 01/01 of each year and it has always included employee dishonesty coverage. John hired Joanne as a cook two years ago. During the time she was employed, from 01/14/14 to 07/13/14, John noticed a strange pattern in the inventory. He couldn’t prove anything but suspected that Joanne was taking inventory. She ended her employment and was arrested in connection with theft at another pizza place in June 2015. She was a first-time offender and confessed to all previous crimes, including her thefts at John’s. John reported the crime as a claim to the company that provided coverage for the 01/01/14 to 01/01/15 policy period. The company denied the claim. He then forwarded the claim to the current carrier and its coverage paid the claim submitted.

 

iThe insurance in paragraph h. above is limited to the lesser of the limits on the current policy or the limits on the policy in effect when the loss occurred.

j. This Optional Coverage defines employee. When used in employee dishonesty, an employee is any natural person:

·         In the named insured's service or for up to 30 days following termination) that the named insured compensates and controls

·         Who acts as a temporary substitute for a regular employee or one hired for certain short-term situations

·         Leased under a written agreement with a labor leasing business to perform certain duties. This does not include temporary employees.

·         Who is a former employee, director, partner, representative, trustee, member, or manager who the named insured retains as a consultant to perform services for the named insured

·         Who is a guest student or intern while working on the premises but not while working away from them

Independent contractors are not employees. Managers, directors, or trustees also are not employees unless they are carrying out the duties of employees.

Note: ISO uses the term “natural person” in the definition above. A natural person means a living, breathing individual. Unnatural persons are entities, such as corporations, that have rights and obligations as defined by law.

Note: This definition of employee matches the same definition in the ISO crime coverage forms.

Related Article: ISO Commercial Crime Coverage Forms And Policies Analysis