Volume 161

MAY 2020

Return to main screen

PF&M ANALYSIS:

ISO Commercial Property

F. DEFINITIONS

The Business Income (and Extra Expense) Coverage Form has six definitions. All should be carefully reviewed because of the impact they have on the coverage being provided.

1. Finished Stock

This is stock that the named insured manufactures. However, there are two exceptions:

  • Whiskey and other alcoholic products are considered stock unless there is a coinsurance percentage for business income on the declarations. This applies only when these items are being aged.
  • Stock that the named insured manufactured and that is held for sale at any retail location premises that this coverage form insures is not considered finished stock.

Note: This term is used in only 5. Additional Coverages c. Extended Business Income. This section states that the extended business income begins even if the finished stock has not been replaced. More importantly, it is used in the causes of loss forms that exclude business income loss due to damage to finished stock and the time to reproduce it.

 

purses for sale

Example: Krissy Chrizmaz has a retail outlet adjacent to its manufacturing plant that has $200,000 in finished stock on its premises. The manufacturing plant itself has $500,000 in finished stock. A tornado damages stock at both locations. Coverage applies for the time needed to replace the stock at the manufacturing plant. There is no coverage for the time needed to replace the stock at the retail outlet. The building and personal property coverage form covers the direct damage to the finished stock. Extended Business Income coverage begins when Krissy resumes operation, although Krissy needs 180 days to replace the damaged finished stock.

2. Operations

a. These are the business activities that occur at the premises described on the declarations.

b. When rental value is included, operations also means whether a tenant can occupy the premises.

Related Court Case: Business Income Held Not Applicable to Building Not Scheduled for Such Coverage

3. Period of Restoration

This is the period of time during which coverage applies. It begins either:

a. Seventy-two hours after the time of covered loss or damage. This applies to business income coverage.

Note: CP 15 56–Business Income Changes–Beginning of the Period of Restoration can be used to reduce the waiting period to 24 hours or to completely eliminate it.

Related Article: CP 15 56–Business Income Changes–Beginning of the Period of Restoration

b. Immediately after the time of covered loss or damage. This applies to extra expense coverage.

Under either of these, coverage ends on either the date when property at the described premises should be repaired, rebuilt, or replaced or the date that the business reopens at a new location. A major sticking point in evaluating when a premises should be ready is the clarifying statement that the repairs, building, or replacing must be done on a timely basis and with substantially similar materials.

 

Example: Maisy May’s hat manufacturing plant uses a custom-built machine. It takes 10 months to build a new machine and deliver it following a covered loss. Maisy May’s insurance carrier believes that Maisy May could have been back in business in four months if she had accepted a similar machine and refuses to pay more than a four-month business income loss.

 

The period of restoration does not include any increased time period required because of an ordinance, regulation, or law being enforced or because of the compliance with any ordinance, regulation, or law regulating construction, use, repair, or demolition of any structure. (10 12 change)

Note: This can cause a significant gap in coverage.

Related Article: CP 15 31–Ordinance or Law–Increased Period of Restoration

The period of restoration also does not include any increased time period required to test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify, neutralize, or in any way respond to or assess the effects of pollutants.

The policy expiration date does not affect the period of restoration.

Related Court Case: Earnings Insurance Held Not Applicable When Motel Was Not Closed By Volcanic Ash

4. Pollutants

These are irritants and contaminants such as smoke, vapor, soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals, and waste of a solid, liquid, gaseous, or thermal nature. Waste includes property to be disposed of, as well as property to be recycled, reconditioned, or reclaimed.

5. Rental Value

This is a specialized type of business income that consists of two parts.

a. The net income, either profit or loss, from tenant(s) that occupy the premises. The fair rental value of the named insured’s occupancy of its own premises is included in the net income amount.

b. The normal operating expenses of the premises that continue after a loss. Examples of such expenses are payroll and tenants’ legal obligations that become the owner’s obligation during the period of time when the premises cannot be occupied.

 

Example: Trey and Margo own a strip shopping center. They have five tenants in addition to their own shop in the center. Heavy ice and snow accumulations cause the roof to cave in and everyone must vacate during the repairs. The monthly business income rental value is as follows:

Rental income from five tenants

$10,000 ($2,000 per tenant)

Trey and Margo’s rental value

$2,000

Payroll

$1,500

Contracted utilities

$2,500

Total monthly rental value

$16,000

Trey and Margo have a rental value loss of $16,000 per month until the damage from the roof collapse is repaired.

6. Suspension

This is either of the following:

  1. The complete closure of the named insured’s business operations or a slowdown.
  2. If rental value coverage is included, it means when tenants cannot occupy all or any portion of the insured premises.