Volume 167

NOVEMBER 2020

Return to main screen

PF&M ANALYSIS:

DWELLING PROPERTY 3 – SPECIAL FORM COVERAGE ANALYSIS

E. Loss Settlement

The settlement provision of the DP 00 03 policy depends upon the class of property that suffers a loss.

1. Settlement on damage to:

  • Personal property
  • Awnings, carpeting, appliances, outdoor antennas and outdoor equipment, and
  • Structures that are not buildings

If items such as the above covered property are damaged, the loss is settled at actual cash value at the time of loss. However, the settlement will not be more than the amount necessary to repair or replace the property.

 

Example: Your client has a ten-year-old sofa that is destroyed in a fire. The insurance company discovers that the same model costs $1,700 today. However, they consider the age and information from the insured about its condition, stains, etc., and determine that its actual cash values is only $319 and that is all that will be offered.

 

Remember, the purpose of insurance is to restore an insured to approximately the same position they enjoyed before the loss. Without this provision, an insured whose loss was based on new or replacement value would be financially enriched by a loss.

2. Settlement on damage to dwelling and other structures:

Loss settlement for this type of property is more complicated. If such property is damaged, settlement may be based on replacement cost (where no deduction is made for depreciation). However, the use of replacement cost is conditional upon the following:

The limit of insurance written on the damaged property must equal at least 80 percent of the structure’s full replacement value.

Although the loss is settled according to replacement cost, the maximum to be paid under the policy is the least expensive among the following:

  • The limit of liability shown on the declarations for the covered property
  • The replacement cost of the portion of structure damaged (using similar materials)
  • The amount necessary to replace or repair the damaged structure

 

Regardless the option, there will be a deduction for the policy deductible.

The settlement is different when the limit of insurance at the time of loss is less than 80% of the structure’s full replacement value. Under this circumstance, the policy will pay the greater of:

  • The actual cash value of the damaged structure
  • The proportional replacement cost value of the damaged structure. The proportion is based upon the relationship between the actual percentage represented by the limit of insurance to the 80% required to trigger full replacement cost coverage.

IMPORTANT: The loss payment will still subtract the deductible and it will be no more than the actual limit of insurance.

In order to determine the amount needed to meet the 80% of full replacement cost requirement, only include the value of the structure that is above the structure’s foundation walls or the lowest basement floor, whichever is applicable.

Only actual cash value of the loss will be paid unless one of the following applies:

a. the damage is fixed

b. the loss amount is less than $2,500 AND less than 5% of the limit of insurance.

Finally, the policy owner has the right to have the loss settled on an actual cash value basis and has up to 180 days (from the loss date) to make claim for any additional amount on a replacement cost basis.