The unexpected happened when Larry was driving down the road. He observed a box sitting in the road directly ahead of him. He immediately swerved to avoid it, but injured himself doing so.
Larry realized that the only way this could happen was if the box fell off another vehicle. In such a case, that vehicle was responsible for the accident.
Although Larry did not know who was responsible for the box, he was confident that it must have been a motorist so he filed an uninsured motorists claim with his carrier, Allstate.
Allstate denied the claim but Larry pursued the case.
Click here to see what the courts decided.