Volume 98

FEBRUARY 2015

Return to main screen

PF&M ANALYSIS:

CG 00 01 AND CG 00 02–COMMERCIAL GENERAL LIABILITY COVERAGE FORMS ANALYSIS

SECTION I–COVERAGES

COVERAGE A–BODILY INJURY AND PROPERTY DAMAGE LIABILITY

2. Exclusions

g.  Aircraft, Auto, or Watercraft (04 13 change)

Coverage does not apply to bodily injury or property damage that arises out of owning, maintaining, using, operating, loading, unloading, or entrusting to others any aircraft, auto, or watercraft that any insured owns, operates, rents, or has loaned to it. This exclusion applies even if a claim alleges that any insured was negligent or engaged in wrongdoing in supervising, hiring, employing, training, or monitoring others.

Example: A watercraft the insured owns and rents to its employees for pleasure use is not properly maintained and an employee is injured when the watercraft sinks. Coverage does not apply to the injury.

This exclusion has five exceptions. It does not apply to:

  • Watercraft on shore at locations the named insured owns or rents
  • Watercraft the named insured does not own that are less than 26 feel long and that are not used to transport people or property for a fee

Example: Ollie at Ollie's Oriental Grill rents a pontoon boat for an afternoon sales presentation and cooks appetizers on a small charcoal grill. The grill causes a fire. The guests move to the other side of the boat to get away from the fire but the weight shift causes the boat to tip and several guests fall into the water. A few are injured. Coverage applies but the pontoon boat's owner will also be involved in any subsequent lawsuits.

  • Autos parked on or on ways next to the named insured's owned or rented locations. Such autos may not be owned by, rented, or loaned to the named insured or any insured.

Example: Ollie's Oriental Grill arranges for valet parking during a dinner it hosts for its top customers at its location. One of the valets inadvertently puts a car he is parking in reverse and pins a woman walking behind it against another vehicle. Coverage applies to the woman's injuries.

  • Liability assumed under any insured contract that applies to owning, maintaining, or using aircraft or watercraft

SmallJet

Example: Ollie charters an emergency flight to meet an important client and the charter company requires it to sign a hold-harmless agreement.

  • Bodily injury or property damage that arises out of operating machinery or equipment attached to or that is part of a land vehicle that qualifies as mobile equipment except that it is subject to a compulsory, financial responsibility, or other motor vehicle insurance law where it is licensed or principally garaged. Bodily injury or property damage caused by operating cherry pickers or similar devices mounted on automotive or truck chassis and used to raise or lower workers or equipment and air compressors, pumps, and generators permanently mounted on self-propelled vehicles is also excepted.

The 04 13 edition deleted the words “in the state” before “where it is licensed” in the prior edition with respect to licensing and garaging locations.

ATV

Example: An all terrain vehicle (ATV) is required to be licensed. A pulley welded to the back of it used to pull a log suddenly swings the log and strikes a person passing by. Coverage applies in this case because the pulley's operation caused the accident, not the ATV.

 

Example:

The well-drilling equipment mounted on a truck chassis accidentally strikes and damages the side of a building while maneuvering into position over a well. Coverage applies to the building damage.

Related Articles:

CA 00 01–Business Auto Coverage Form Analysis

Aircraft Insurance Coverage Analysis

ISO Commercial General Liability Coverage Forms Available Endorsements and Their Uses states that CG 24 12–Boats deletes the watercraft exclusion and extends coverage to certain boats.

Related Court Case: Injury from Truck Damage to Sidewalk Held Not Within Automobile Exclusion