The City of New Orleans issued a mandatory evacuation order because Hurricane Gustav was approaching. Brennan's, a local restaurant, was forced to close, and therefore sustained a significant business income loss. Brennan's property policy with Lexington provided limited civil authority business income coverage so it made a business income loss claim.
Lexington denied coverage because the only direct damage Gustav caused was to property located on islands in the Caribbean. Its argument was that the civil authority coverage did not apply because Brennan's was not close enough to where the actual damage occurred.
Click here to see the court's opinion of the proximity argument.